skip to content
  1. Home
  2. >
  3. Investment Q&A
You can view 3 more answers this month. Sign up for a free trial for unlimited access.

Investment Q&A

Not investment advice or solicitation to buy/sell securities. Do your own due diligence and/or consult an advisor.

Q: Today I asked the following question

"I am looking at hedged ETF's and specifically VSP. I was interested to see how well the ETF tracked the index and found that over a 5 year time frame - it underperformed by about 11%. (Total return for VSP is 81.0% and SPX is 93.33% - The Vanguard US ETF - VOO tracks SPX almost exactly.) I am assuming that this underperformance is because the hedging strategy is not perfect?? .......or does the 11% difference represent the cost of hedging?? Also - would other hedged ETF's have similar comparisons?? Thanks"

The answer

"The performance difference is not that the hedge doesn't work, it is because it does. VSP takes away the currency impact. The Canadian dollar has been quite weak over the time period noted, so VSP has not benefitted from the rise of the US$ vs the C$. "

This answer makes no sense.
If VSP takes away the currency impact - the returns should match the S&P 500 Index ....that is the whole point of hedging - but its 11% off - that is the question. It is either because the hedging strategy is not effective or its due to the cost of the hedge.


The unhedged equivalent Vanguard Canada ETF VFV outperforms the S&P 500 index as you would expect due to the weaking CAD........because it is unhedged....which makes sense.
Read Answer Asked by Gary on December 06, 2024
Q: I hold CSH and CRR. The later being a very small position (1%) I'm looking to consolidate. Could you rank these 3 or do you have a better REIT to suggest?
Thanks
Read Answer Asked by Robert on December 06, 2024
Q: Hi, just looking at CPX, (unbelievable). I missed out on this one , not my first or last miss, but was wondering if you could provide two or three recommendations that are geared towards the electrification boom that is here or coming. (I already have HPS.A) or is CPX still the one to buy?
Thanks
Read Answer Asked by Brad on December 06, 2024
Q: Retired, dividend-income investor. Long, long term holder of BCE in my wife's cash account. Sold it in mid-Nov, captured a $12k cap loss, and plan to buy it back next week....prior to the ex-dividend date.

I am ok buying it at the roughly $38 level, even if it floats around that level for the short to medium term. I understand that there might even be some further downside risk. I plan to buy around 1400 shares, either in one shot or maybe 2-3 tranches.

Your opinion on which makes more sense in this case? Multiple purchases is the more conservative way to go, but one shot gets the full dividend back (and more) to where we were a month ago. The BCE board has said they would not touch the dividend for now....although their credibility has taken a hit lately. We are ok with "some" volatility. It's almost a "flip a coin" decision.

Thanks for your help...Steve
Read Answer Asked by Stephen on December 06, 2024
Q: Hello Team, It seems to me from reading the odd comment that you are not very keen on buying the TSX hedged US securities in their Canadian listing and currency and prefer to buy the corresponding security on US exchanges in their original US listing and currency. Can you please explain the reason? Thank you.
Read Answer Asked by Adel on December 06, 2024
Q: Hello, in light of the Canadian dollar trending lower recently, does it make more sense to buy CDR’s as opposed to the equivalent US listed stocks? Since CDR’s are traded in Canadian currency on a Canadian exchange I can still buy the same amount of shares with my Canadian dollars even if the dollar drops as opposed to buying US listed shares on a U.S. exchange with my Canadian dollars which should cost me more as the Canadian dollar drops. Many thanks for the amazing service that you provide.
Read Answer Asked by Anthony on December 06, 2024
Q: Do you know of any Consumer Discretionary ETF's that trade on the TSX?
Read Answer Asked by David C. on December 06, 2024