skip to content
  1. Home
  2. >
  3. Investment Q&A
You can view 3 more answers this month. Sign up for a free trial for unlimited access.

Investment Q&A

Not investment advice or solicitation to buy/sell securities. Do your own due diligence and/or consult an advisor.

Q: Do you consider either railway a good new investment right now? I used your interactive chart to compare the two, and if you bought CNR 10 years ago you are probably pretty happy, but over the last 5 years CP outperformed, and ytd CP has ground up a bit while CN has drifted down. In the current interest rate environment I don’t think anyone is buying either for the dividend? Is there an investment thesis here somewhere or are there just plain better ideas? Thanks for your thoughts.
Read Answer Asked by Stephen R. on September 11, 2023
Q: Hi Peter, why the sell of on the rails - in particular to CN and CP. Was there any news that affected them directly. Also would you consider them a buy and if so which one would you add. Can you also speak to evaluation. Thank you
Read Answer Asked by Frank on May 24, 2023
Q: I would like to buy a railroad for my son's portfolio. I note the Cdn railroads are currently more expensive on a PE basis than the US rails. This would be a long-term hold (he is 29 yoa, and going into RSP). What would be 5i's preferred choice? If you think CP or CNR, I am not opposed to waiting for a more favourable entry point.
Read Answer Asked by Bob on May 18, 2023
Q: If I invested in a saving account for my son and daughter in the Royal Bank, Enbridge and Berkshire for 15 years, would this approach work? My daughter is 16 and my son is 14.
Read Answer Asked by CARMELO on May 09, 2023
Q: I need to choose one railway stock for my rrsp, out of the 3 which one would you say has more upside to it.
Read Answer Asked by wilson on May 08, 2023
Q: What is your view on CP results today? Would you view. p to be a buy? Do you have a preference for either CP or TFII for additional purchases right now to increase industrial sector exposure?
Read Answer Asked by Gerry on April 27, 2023
Q: If one were to sell Magna but still wanted to stay in the industrial sector would you endorse moving into CPR at this time (allowing for giving up some dividend income)? CPR share price has gone pretty parabolic in the last 5 years or so relative to their long term history, do you think the valuation has gotten ahead of itself?

In spite of its smaller size I was interested in ATS but after the unexplained drop last week on higher volume I’m waiting for the other shoe to drop. I don’t mean to editorialize but I can’t count the number of times in recent years when unexplained drops suddenly become clear in the days and weeks that follow. It’s just a personal opinion but I really feel ethics aren’t what they once were, and whether it is an insider, a printer, or someone else “in the know”, it seems information gets leaked and unlike years ago there is now a variety of means (like social media) for that info to spread quickly and widely. End of rant.

Thanks!
Read Answer Asked by Stephen R. on April 11, 2023
Q: Hello, we need to increase our weighting in Industrials, with current holdings mostly CNR (5%). Based on various BNN guests views and as finetuned with 5i recommendations, we have shortlisted these 3 names and the intention is to build at least 3% weighting, in each or all of these names. Could you please rank them based on your conviction. Also, would appreciate it if you could also provide a decent entry level as well as an Excellent Buy price. Thank You
Read Answer Asked by rajeev on March 01, 2023
Q: I heard these companies earnings were posted recently. Could you please discuss the earnings and help me to understand them? Thanks,
Read Answer Asked by Lin on January 27, 2023
Q: If you had to choose one of these stocks, which would you choose for long term hold and why?
Thx
Read Answer Asked by Todd on January 16, 2023
Q: Need to rebuild industrial sector holdings - assume a clean slate. What percentage to invest in each subcategory with top picks [some suggested names-please provide your 2 or 3 top picks] and target buy price would be very helpful. (1) Engineering & Construction- WSP, NVEE, J, KBR, ETN and PWR [for electrification]; (2) Transportation- CNR, CP, TFII, CJT; (3) Goods: LMT, NOC, TDG, BWXT, DE, FLNG, FREY; (4) Services: WCN, GFL, TRI. Thank you.
Read Answer Asked by sam on November 30, 2022
Q: Please provide your top five Canadian and top five U.S companies that you consider to have superior pricing power. Thanks
Read Answer Asked by Greg on November 16, 2022
Q: The two Canadian railway companies have out-performed CSX this year. Any explanations? Which one is a buy now? CSX seems much cheaper.

Thanks,
Liping
Read Answer Asked by Liping on October 12, 2022