Q: Hi if 2020 earning forcast less then 2019, would you still hold on to the stock? 
        
    
    You can view 3 more answers this month. Sign up for a free trial for unlimited access.
    
                                                                                                    Investment Q&A
Not investment advice or solicitation to buy/sell securities. Do your own due diligence and/or consult an advisor.
            Q: According to INK Research the CEO of ATD (Hannasch) sold all his ATD shares ($10 million) in mid Apr. Any word on the reason?  
Many thanks. Bob
        
    Many thanks. Bob
            Q: What would be your preference today of these two stocks in the consumer sector?
        
    
            Q: The access I have to consensus estimates shows Couche-Tard is expected to make $3.42US in 2019 and $3.37US in 2020. Can I get you to confirm if this is accurate? If accurate, what accounts for the drop in earnings expected in 2020?
Thanks.
John
    Thanks.
John
- 
        
                             Toronto-Dominion Bank (The) (TD $115.04) Toronto-Dominion Bank (The) (TD $115.04)
- 
        
                             Stars Group Inc. (The) (TSGI $37.49) Stars Group Inc. (The) (TSGI $37.49)
- 
        
                             Descartes Systems Group Inc. (The) (DSG $123.83) Descartes Systems Group Inc. (The) (DSG $123.83)
- 
        
                             NFI Group Inc. (NFI $14.00) NFI Group Inc. (NFI $14.00)
- 
        
                             Kinaxis Inc. (KXS $167.84) Kinaxis Inc. (KXS $167.84)
- 
        
                             Alimentation Couche-Tard Inc. (ATD $70.89) Alimentation Couche-Tard Inc. (ATD $70.89)
- 
        
                             Premium Brands Holdings Corporation (PBH $95.54) Premium Brands Holdings Corporation (PBH $95.54)
- 
        
                             Spin Master Corp. Subordinate Voting Shares (TOY $20.53) Spin Master Corp. Subordinate Voting Shares (TOY $20.53)
            Q:    Hi Peter and 5i team,
We have 11% cash in our grandsons RESP (age 5) and we want to deploy the money. The listed stocks are currently in his account. What would be a good choice for a new holding or top up a current holding. Thank you for your great advice in the past.
    We have 11% cash in our grandsons RESP (age 5) and we want to deploy the money. The listed stocks are currently in his account. What would be a good choice for a new holding or top up a current holding. Thank you for your great advice in the past.
- 
        
                             Alimentation Couche-Tard Inc. (ATD $70.89) Alimentation Couche-Tard Inc. (ATD $70.89)
- 
        
                             iShares S&P/TSX Capped Consumer Staples Index ETF (XST $58.09) iShares S&P/TSX Capped Consumer Staples Index ETF (XST $58.09)
            Q: I continue to be concerned about the market and corrections and being somewhat more defensive in my holdings.  ATD.B has been held at about 3% of my total portfolio for about 3 years and it has met my expectations.  Nevertheless, I realize I am under-diversified in the consumer staples sector.  Would selling my ATD.B and buying XST, perhaps to a 5% level, be wise, in your opinion, or just me letting anxiety leading me to some 'churning'.  I'm a senior-plus so at a stage of withdrawing from my accounts for some income.
Thanks for your input and forgive the wordiness.
    Thanks for your input and forgive the wordiness.
            Q: Would this be a good time to purchase ATD?   What's the difference between ATD.A vs ATD.B, which one would you purchase?  Do companies typically offer A class vs B class shares, whats the best option for individual investors.
Thanks,
Neeraj
    Thanks,
Neeraj
            Q: I was looking for some Canadian blue chip shares to buy as long-term holds. Since both financials and energy have not done well in Canada in recent years I had to look outside those sectors. What is your opinion on these candidates? Any additional suggestions? Thank you as usual four your valuable advice.
Walter
    Walter
            Q: comments please on the quarter??
        
    
            Q: reorts tomorrow do you have estimates please?? 
        
    
            Q: Hi,
Im looking for a lo-volatility, long term steady performer. What do you think of ATD.B or TRI.CI. What do you think of these two choices? Any better ideas?
    Im looking for a lo-volatility, long term steady performer. What do you think of ATD.B or TRI.CI. What do you think of these two choices? Any better ideas?
- 
        
                             Constellation Software Inc. (CSU $3,604.18) Constellation Software Inc. (CSU $3,604.18)
- 
        
                             Great Canadian Gaming Corporation (GC $44.98) Great Canadian Gaming Corporation (GC $44.98)
- 
        
                             Alimentation Couche-Tard Inc. (ATD $70.89) Alimentation Couche-Tard Inc. (ATD $70.89)
- 
        
                             Shopify Inc. Class A Subordinate Voting Shares (SHOP $242.97) Shopify Inc. Class A Subordinate Voting Shares (SHOP $242.97)
- 
        
                             goeasy Ltd. (GSY $168.21) goeasy Ltd. (GSY $168.21)
            Q: What are you top 5 ideas at current time, amongst all three of the portfolios ?
Thank you
    Thank you
            Q: Our portfolio largely follows your balanced model, and I see we're somewhat overweight in Consumer Non Cyclical. If you were to lighten up on one of these three, which would it be?
        
    
            Q: hello 5i:
Long time holders of both of the above companies and intend to add to one. Have read the questions submitted in the past, but am wondering which of these companies would you favour:
A.) as far as total returns are concerned
B.) as far as safety is concerned
C.) as far as present valuations are concerned, adding in future growth possibilities
thanks, and deduct as many credits as necessary.
ps. Bought these companies YEARS ago, based on 5i recommendation. While they haven't quite been CSUs - what has? - my only regret is that we didn't buy more. Kudos to you Peter, as Ryan wasn't around back then.
    Long time holders of both of the above companies and intend to add to one. Have read the questions submitted in the past, but am wondering which of these companies would you favour:
A.) as far as total returns are concerned
B.) as far as safety is concerned
C.) as far as present valuations are concerned, adding in future growth possibilities
thanks, and deduct as many credits as necessary.
ps. Bought these companies YEARS ago, based on 5i recommendation. While they haven't quite been CSUs - what has? - my only regret is that we didn't buy more. Kudos to you Peter, as Ryan wasn't around back then.
            Q: Up nicely on ATD.B and not considering selling but wonder if PKI is worth an add as well.  I do not own many stocks similar to ATD so no issues with balancing.  What, would the case be for owning PKI and is it one you endorse strongly?
        
    
            Q: I have a position in PBH and it has not done well recently although it has performed well in the past. Are there any issues with PBH? I am considering selling half and getting a half position on ATD.B. I would love to hear your thoughts. Thanks. SHyam
        
    
            Q: When is ATD.B expected to report? Thank you.
        
    
            Q: Is there any news to account for the share price climb in Couche-Tard today? I am thinking about adding to my position now that it has broken its multi-year consolidation trend. Your thoughts please. Thanks.
        
    
            Q: Are the two companies competing against each other ? Which of the two do you prefer for stability and growth?
        
    - 
        
                             Covalon Technologies Ltd. (COV $2.29) Covalon Technologies Ltd. (COV $2.29)
- 
        
                             Bank of Nova Scotia (The) (BNS $91.69) Bank of Nova Scotia (The) (BNS $91.69)
- 
        
                             BCE Inc. (BCE $32.27) BCE Inc. (BCE $32.27)
- 
        
                             Brookfield Renewable Partners L.P. (BEP.UN $42.54) Brookfield Renewable Partners L.P. (BEP.UN $42.54)
- 
        
                             CCL Industries Inc. Unlimited Class B Non-Voting Shares (CCL.B $77.43) CCL Industries Inc. Unlimited Class B Non-Voting Shares (CCL.B $77.43)
- 
        
                             Methanex Corporation (MX $53.81) Methanex Corporation (MX $53.81)
- 
        
                             WSP Global Inc. (WSP $270.13) WSP Global Inc. (WSP $270.13)
- 
        
                             Algonquin Power & Utilities Corp. (AQN $7.79) Algonquin Power & Utilities Corp. (AQN $7.79)
- 
        
                             Stars Group Inc. (The) (TSGI $37.49) Stars Group Inc. (The) (TSGI $37.49)
- 
        
                             Kinaxis Inc. (KXS $167.84) Kinaxis Inc. (KXS $167.84)
- 
        
                             Magna International Inc. (MG $65.04) Magna International Inc. (MG $65.04)
- 
        
                             Alimentation Couche-Tard Inc. (ATD $70.89) Alimentation Couche-Tard Inc. (ATD $70.89)
- 
        
                             Premium Brands Holdings Corporation (PBH $95.54) Premium Brands Holdings Corporation (PBH $95.54)
- 
        
                             Savaria Corporation (SIS $21.88) Savaria Corporation (SIS $21.88)
- 
        
                             CI Morningstar Canada Momentum Index ETF (WXM $40.55) CI Morningstar Canada Momentum Index ETF (WXM $40.55)
            Q: In my portfolio I have following Canadian equities: AQN (4.9%), BCE (4.78%), BNS (4.64%), WXM (4.5%), SIS (3.8%), BEP (2.68%), MG (2.29%), KXS (2.03%), PBH (1.94%), MX (1.92%), COV (1.87%), TSGI (1.76%). 
I have a full positions worth of cash I would like to add to my Canadian content and was wondering on your thoughts as to adding to one new stock (ATD.B, WSP, CCL.B, other suggestion), 2 half positions, or adding to my existing positions.
I have a 20 year time frame and comfortable with some risk.
Thank you.
    I have a full positions worth of cash I would like to add to my Canadian content and was wondering on your thoughts as to adding to one new stock (ATD.B, WSP, CCL.B, other suggestion), 2 half positions, or adding to my existing positions.
I have a 20 year time frame and comfortable with some risk.
Thank you.
 
                             
                             
                    