skip to content
  1. Home
  2. >
  3. Investment Q&A
You can view 3 more answers this month. Sign up for a free trial for unlimited access.

Investment Q&A

Not investment advice or solicitation to buy/sell securities. Do your own due diligence and/or consult an advisor.

Q: Hi Peter and Ryan, I'm just making sure I understand the withdrawal rules correctly in dealing with TFSA accounts. I have some cash accumulated from the payments of dividends during the last few months in my TFSA. Am I allowed to withdraw say $2,000.00 in cash from my TFSA account in the next few days (before December 31). Then after Jan 1st, 2017, does my new limit for 2017 become $7,500.00? If so can I transfer (in kind) shares from a cash account worth $7,500.00 into my TFSA without issues? Thank you so much for all you do and all the best in the new year. Mario.
Read Answer Asked by Mario on December 20, 2016
Q: I am considering moving some or all of these from a cash account to a TFSA. Would you agree with this move and if so is there a particular order or any that you would leave out. Thanx Robbie
Read Answer Asked by Robert on December 19, 2016
Q: A comment by a member on his tsfa contribution .in my opinion the tsfa naps been the the best investment vehicle that ever was created and I will always be thank full to the Harper gov for introducing it .
My wife and I generate $600 tax free every month in dividends and in the new with add 7200 that we took out plus our 11000 allowance .
We have found lif rif and Resp to be a burden in our old age i view it as money behind the wall and withdrawals cause claw backs to our oas .
I would encourage ever one to take advantage to what I believe is the best investment vehicle ever introduced
Best regards
Stan
Read Answer Asked by Stan on December 15, 2016
Q: Hello 5i team,
I think it is time for my wife to redeploy her cash position in the combined RRSP and TFSA portfolios.
I’m listing below her current holdings by the various TSX sectors, by weight and my proposed choice of additions. I would appreciate your opinion as to your order of preference at this time.
Consumer cyclicals (11%) CGX, MG; propose CCL, BYD or TOY
Consumer defensives (0%); propose ATD, DOL or PBH
Energy (8%) ENB, KEY: propose a producer
Financials (13%) SLF, TD; propose any addition?
Health (6%) ZUH; propose any addition?
Industrials (7%) BIP.UN; propose CNR, SIS, STN, WSP
Materials (0%); propose MX or SJ
Info tech (13%) CSU, GIB; propose ENGH, KXS or SYZ
RE/Telcos/Utilities (15%) BCE, BEP.UN, CIGI, FSC; propose reduce BCE or sell CIGI
Cash (26%)
I would not mind that you deduct any number of credits.
Thanks,
Antoine
Read Answer Asked by Antoine on December 12, 2016
Q: Hello Peter et al:

We are "nearly retired"! We hope NOT to need TFSA in the near future, may be not ever! RRSPs and non-RRSPs are fairly well diversified. The question(s) are: Do we need to still contribute to TFSA? (We haven't contributed to RRSPs in a few years.)
If we do contribute $ 5500 each 11k for both of us what two stocks ( one each per a/c) will you recommend? Our major risk factors are health (always unpredictable at this stage in one's life) and (adult) kids who are at the mercy of our politicians and their policies.
Thank you for all your help.
Mano.

P.S. One small suggestion....not sure if this can be pulled off at CMS or not. If in some way Ross Grant can give his BTSX portfolio in January issue, it would be cool. I know technically it may be difficult. But even if it can be uploaded on the CMS web site within a week and then appear in February issue, it will fine.
Read Answer Asked by Savalai on December 12, 2016
Q: I have built up a 83k TFSA by using a mix of picks i have chosen on my own and with your valued advice but find it very stressful at times and would like to put it in hands of a trusted investment fund(s).I am seeking your opinion on dividing the TFSA into the three funds offered by Edgehill Funds.Guardian ,Advantage,and Select.Would this be a good strategy or should i continue to stock pick among your holdings in your funds.I am looking to retire in 10 years and this would represent 15% of my retirement total
Read Answer Asked by Brad on December 12, 2016
Q: Hello,
I currently work for a company that has a share ownership program where my contributions are non-tax sheltered, while the matching contribution from my employer is tax sheltered. Starting Jan.1st they are now offering an option to have my personal bi-weekly contribution go into a TFSA instead of the non-tax sheltered option. Seems like a good option to me but I'd like to get your thoughts/comments before I make a decision. Thanks!
Read Answer Asked by Patricia on December 06, 2016
Q: I manage my husband's and my TFSA's as if they are one account so we do not duplicate the stocks in the 2 accounts and can have a reasonable size of position. We have a similar weighting of ALA, REI.UN, SIA, WSP, ZEB, BEP.UN, CGX, and HR.UN and PKI, and a double weighting of CPD and CDZ. We currently have about $110K in the two accounts and $20K of that is in cash. Can you suggest what we might add to or change in the above list, considering that we prefer income paying securities with some growth prospects and want the TFSA's to act independently of our other investments as a relatively conservative growth vehicle.
Read Answer Asked by Maria on December 02, 2016
Q: I hold HCG and MFA in TFSAs at 1.4 and 1.8 percent, respectively, of my & my husband's total portfolio. (combined calculation as recommended by 5i!) They are both down close to 30% since I bought them. Given their percentages, should I just leave them, or should I take my loss in one or both, and move on? Thanks for your help and support.
Read Answer Asked by M.S. on November 24, 2016
Q: I'm helping my daughter (mid-20s) manage her TFSA, which is her only portfolio. Currently, it consists of IPL 30%, TOY 28% , SIS 18% and KXS 23%. She’s wants to keep TOY, SIS and KXS, but is thinking of selling IPL. She is more interested in growth stocks. Do you consider selling IPL a good move or is it best to keep it; and, can you suggest 2-3 other stocks to add to round things out, given the other holdings. She's looking at a minimum 3-5 year timeframe.
Read Answer Asked by Lois on November 23, 2016
Looking for more? Sign up for a FREE 14 day trial! No credit card required

We invite you to sign up for a 14 day free trial of 5i Research!
Experience all the benefits and tools we have to offer; stock research, model portfolios, Q&A with our experts, and so much more. Join a community of like-minded investors today!