Q: Re: Q concerning 5i patron's grandson with 2k to invest; should it be placed inside a TFSA?
My two adult / student offspring were recently in a similar situation and I agree with all that you said but would like to add some additional info:
- TD bank is currently running a promotion that if a person opens a new TFSA, they will have $100 placed inside the account in Mar 20' (promotion ends early Mar I believe)
- If the TFSA is opened at a TD branch (not a brokerage account) then there is no fee
- The TFSA account can have GICs, mutual funds and/or a cash component however, only a GIC or mutual fund will qualify the account for the $100 bonus
For each of my kids, I had them buy a one yr GIC (approx 1.6% as I recall) and place some short term cash in the cash component of the TFSA; the cash earns approx 1%.
You are right in saying that there will not really be much benefit to be gained but there are some intangibles to be considered: this is a great financial learning experience for a young person, the $ is placed out of their immediate grasp until they are more likely to need it and $100 is a terrific bonus for a small account.
Steve
My two adult / student offspring were recently in a similar situation and I agree with all that you said but would like to add some additional info:
- TD bank is currently running a promotion that if a person opens a new TFSA, they will have $100 placed inside the account in Mar 20' (promotion ends early Mar I believe)
- If the TFSA is opened at a TD branch (not a brokerage account) then there is no fee
- The TFSA account can have GICs, mutual funds and/or a cash component however, only a GIC or mutual fund will qualify the account for the $100 bonus
For each of my kids, I had them buy a one yr GIC (approx 1.6% as I recall) and place some short term cash in the cash component of the TFSA; the cash earns approx 1%.
You are right in saying that there will not really be much benefit to be gained but there are some intangibles to be considered: this is a great financial learning experience for a young person, the $ is placed out of their immediate grasp until they are more likely to need it and $100 is a terrific bonus for a small account.
Steve