Q: Just finished reading Peters article in the latest edition of Canadian Money about High yield dividend payers. Question about payout ratios. Its confusing.
Example; In Morningstar for 2018 the payout ratio was quoted at 134%(unsustainable)
Using operating cash flow the calculation is 230M/388M = 60%(sustainable)
Using free cash flow the calculation is 230M/322M= 71%(probably sustainable)
Peter you have said the calculations should use either free or operating cash flow for the calculations of payout ratio.
I contacted Morningstar asking about their calculation and they said they use what the company sends them.
So which is right when trying to figure out whether the payout ratio is too high?
There are multiple other examples, Enbridge to name one.
Stated payout ratio 282%, operating. cash flow calc, 3844/10502=37%
Free cash flow 3844/3156 = 121%. Quite a variance. I'm confused.
WHICH CALCULATION IS THE BEST ONE TO USE TO HELP DETERMINE SUSTAINABILITY?
Example; In Morningstar for 2018 the payout ratio was quoted at 134%(unsustainable)
Using operating cash flow the calculation is 230M/388M = 60%(sustainable)
Using free cash flow the calculation is 230M/322M= 71%(probably sustainable)
Peter you have said the calculations should use either free or operating cash flow for the calculations of payout ratio.
I contacted Morningstar asking about their calculation and they said they use what the company sends them.
So which is right when trying to figure out whether the payout ratio is too high?
There are multiple other examples, Enbridge to name one.
Stated payout ratio 282%, operating. cash flow calc, 3844/10502=37%
Free cash flow 3844/3156 = 121%. Quite a variance. I'm confused.
WHICH CALCULATION IS THE BEST ONE TO USE TO HELP DETERMINE SUSTAINABILITY?