Investment Q&A

Q: An observation/rant regarding TFSA accounts.

It appears per the media that the good ol' gov't lied to us CDN.'s about what we could do within a TFSA account or at least set people up so they could get their taxes from people's TFSA (TAX FREE Savings Account) in the future (starting now).

As I understand, the gov't said stock(s) could be bought & owned within a TFSA. But the gov't never said there was a minimum time period that any specific stock had to be held and owned for. So the smart ones who know how to trade during shorter time frames, or put lots of the their TFSA into say, SHOP-tsx, CSU-tsx, KXS-tsx... have grown their TFSA to as much as $1 million dollars and a few have even grown theirs beyond that per the media.

It appears the gov't wants its cut now.

As a long time (decades) investor and trader I take objection to the media and financial world's BS around the issue that "Investing" is holding for a longer time and "Trading" is "Gambling" when done in shorter time frames.

I have always seen Trading and Investing as the same thing. That being, speculating that the stock's price will be higher in the future, (setting aside Shorting) be it, 5 minutes, 5 years or 5 decades. It is an unknown and some may say either is pure speculation or gambling. Both are trading over different time frame periods. That is the only difference. Period.

Technicals and Fundamentals are both used to project (speculate) about the future.

To use a real but just singular & extreme example, of the original big companies from the original DOW only GE remains. So if anyone bought the original DOW (or if there had been a DOW ETF) and "Invested" by holding they would now be on welfare as they would be broke. So Investing is not any better than Trading (knowledge is required to succeed in either).

5iResearch also trades regularly, as do investors like Warren Buffet.

So I wish our gov't, the media and financial industry would stop playing games with us so regular people can make some $$$ so as to support themselves, spend $$ on goods, start businesses to give people employment, ...

Lastly, if those with a TFSA of say $100k, $500k or $1 million have not removed any $$$ from the TFSA are they not SAVING it in a TFSA (Tax Free SAVINGS Account)?

Have a great day!

Q: I have held HR.UN for a few years and have not really like this stock but kept it as you often said it was a good REIT stock.I would be generating a small capital loss if I sell HR.UN but wonder if buying CSH.UN is a better option in the long term. I own no other REIT stock.

Thanks

Q: Would you recommend buying this REIT, now that it's at a 52 week low? The goal is long term dividend growth. I'm open to other suggestions?

Q: The article you shared about the Canadian banks was an interesting read. I'm curious if you would buy any of the banks today, and if so which one and why? Its interesting to hear your thought process around whether you would go for the higher dividend payer that is more undervalued but limited short term growth, or the more US exposed fair valued, or international fair valued, or other reasons.

Q: Have held crt.un since it was started. Want some growth - is it still a hold? If sell, any suggestions for replacement?

Q: I am up $2000 on ABBV. Its p/b is 24. I am holding for the dividend. Is it time to replace this with MRK?

Q: Is the Amendment of SGRS Royalties LP Credit Facility, Sutton Royalty Rate Increase announced have any significants? Particularly towards helping with their pay out ratio?
Thank You

Q: The Globe shows OTEX with a trailing PE of 7 and a forward PE of 20.
Is that accurate - is the company expected to do poorly next year?

Q: Surely, among the 58,000 questions which you answered there are some about your views on John Bogle's idea of "Don't look for the needle in the haystack. Just buy the haystack." How can I find them?
Alternatively, can I have your views now?
Thank you

Q: What are your thoughts about this company and buying the convertible debentures offered by Canaccord

Q: reviewing your reports i like to add CAE and CSU to my cash account and CGX to retirement account.
i dont like to add to the number of my holding or the margin.
So i would consider letting go of CJT (recent purchase ) reduce my TD (FROM 300 to 200 units ) ZZZ (reluctantly, t has done well in the short time ). IN MY RET A/C let go of DIV .
Appreciate your feedback

replace DIV with CGX in my retirement account (i am surprised at your A- rating for CJX

Q: Hello

I parked some cash in HFR, suppose interest rates go up will HFR be net down?

Thanks

Q: We are still sitting with 20% cash waiting to deploy on downturn. Would like to enter market soon in your income portfolio and increase a 1.5% holding in IGM or other tech etf. Would now be a good time begin on the income portfolio and which tech etf would you favor. Thanks for your great service.

Q: It's frustrating to own a stock like EIS that is infested by the short sellers who have no scruples about the interests of other investors in order to get their loots.

Have there been prior class action suits of the shareholders taken the short sellers to court for compensation if their basis of shorting the company happens to be false or pure fabrications? Are there lawyers who specializes in these type of suits?

Just curious. After all the door should be able to swing both ways.

Q: A year or more back I read an article in the Globe that said if you wanted to exchange currency USD/CAD you could purchase an interlisted stock through an exchange in one country and then sell that stock through an exchange in the other country.

Is this correct and is it that simple? If I held RY, say, purchased on TSE could I place a sell order that specified it be sold on the NYSE? Just like a regular transaction - no phone calls, no special fees?

Q: These 3 companies represent 5% of my portfolia. I was thinking of adding more BEAT. Can you give me your thoughts on BEAT? I could not find any reference to it under member questions.

Q: Hi Whats pushing this stock and hi volumes
Stan

Q: What industry would you put BYD.UN under?

Thanks

Q: Hello to all of you at 5i,
I'm debating whether to buy shares of Borg Warner so as to diversify outside of North America or make a move on Magna for almost the same reason given it does a lot of business in Europe. Which one do you see as having the better prospects? Thanks in advance.
Robert

Q: Seems to have corrected recently on a (complex?) financing. Your current opinion, please. Thanks Jim