skip to content
  1. Home
  2. >
  3. Investment Q&A
You can view 3 more answers this month. Sign up for a free trial for unlimited access.

Investment Q&A

Not investment advice or solicitation to buy/sell securities. Do your own due diligence and/or consult an advisor.

Q: Hello: I thought I heard David Driscoll on BNN the other day saying that when holding "cash" for clients in Canadian accounts he buys Bankers acceptance notes. Could you please help me understand what these are and how they compare to other fixed income products such as GICs. Thanks very much
Marilyn
Read Answer Asked by Marilyn on August 14, 2018
Q: As a small investor I am getting tired of companies issuing more shares to line their pockets ,a lot of times it is for a good purpose but lately it seems they are just cashing in and hurting investors .In the past I would vote on these matters but don't any more when I realized how futile it was.The big pension funds should be holding these boards accountable as they have most of the shares ,are they all scrubbing each others back? When you look at the compensation these ceo's and boards make the greed is getting ridiculous .I think they are making enough without having to raid my bank account. Sorry for the rant but something has to change.
Read Answer Asked by lynn on August 14, 2018
Q: Would you tell me what is the influence on Cdn stocks for those listed on an American Exchange?
Proportion of total daily trades that are American?
Arbitrage that exists?
Will American trades still operate when our TSX is closed for a holiday?
If so, is there any relationship between a closing price on the American Exchange and the next day opening price of the Cdn Exchange?
Why have I never read about this before?
George Murphy
Read Answer Asked by GEORGE on August 13, 2018
Q: Even though I'm approaching my 81st birthday, I am not, nor have I ever been a fan of the old balanced approach to portfolio composition, although I am quite aware that circumstances for some people may make that approach desirable. Just because I'm old doesn't mean I want bonds (which I don't really understand anyway).
I just spend a half hour comparing your three portfolios and my opinion has been justified in spades. I looked at the 3 year annualized performance, the maximum drawdown, profitable periods, losing periods and the up standard deviation.
The standard deviation for the BE portfolio is higher than the Income portfolio but that's the only metric that I would consider positive. The 3 year annualized performance of the BE is 12.95% vs. 4.51% for the income but most alarming was the maximum drawdown; that's the metric I thought the income portfolio investor would be looking for, that is a minimum drawdown. But the maximum drawdown for the BE is 6.8% compared to that of the income portfolio of 8.59%.
Okay, so here are my questions: Am I wrong in my all equities portfolio even at my age? Am I missing something in my interpretation of the results? And, why would anybody want to go income given the superior numbers of the balanced equity?
Read Answer Asked by Fred on August 09, 2018
Q: I'm planning to retire next year and looking for planning resources. We are about to meet with a fee for service planner, but would also like to explore online planning tools. Can 5i or perhaps the membership suggest a useful tool that I can play around with.
I would also like to mention that our plan is looking much healthier due to investment gains, almost double, made by following 5i recommendations over the last 4 years of membership.
Anytime you're in Winnipeg drop by for a beer.
Cheers and thanks, Peter.
Read Answer Asked by Peter on August 09, 2018
Q: "Anonymous Trading" what is ,and why is it allowed??
Thanks
Read Answer Asked by Mike on August 07, 2018
Q: On June 23, the Wall Street Journal published an article titled "Forget the 4% Rule: Rethinking Common Retirement Beliefs". Among other issues, the WSJ article states:
“When saving for retirement, calculate your “number”— the amount you’ll need without running a big risk of depleting your savings. When in retirement, spend no more than 4% of your initial balance, adjusted annually for inflation.
Investing in the market has long been considered to be a reliable way to protect one’s assets against inflation. Is adjusting “annually for inflation” really necessary?
Read Answer Asked by Milan on August 07, 2018
Q: I believe you responded to a question about variable vs fixed mortgages awhile ago, however I would appreciate your opinion at this time. I realize the individual $/circumstances but I was wondering what your thoughts would be. Thanks Paul
Read Answer Asked by Paul on August 07, 2018
Q: Hi 5I,
How would a small investor get in to Private equities. This only seems possible for High Net Worth Clients. Is there good Publicly traded company's or ETF's that focus on Private equities. Is this a type of asset class that is recommended to diversify your portofolio.
Thank you
Read Answer Asked by André on August 07, 2018
Q: I own shares in Volkswagen. I have received a corporate action notice advising that they are cancelling the Ordinary share sponsored ADR program. I have the option to either receive 2 Unsponsored ordinary share ADRs for each Sponsored ordinary share ADR exchanged or exchange 5 ADRs plus pay any charges or fees per ADR to receive one ordinary share of Volkswagen AG.

Why would a company terminate sponsored ADRs? Would it be better to reveive Unsponsored ADRs or Ordinary shares?

Read Answer Asked by Grant on August 07, 2018
Q: Hi 5i - my kids will start University in 6 and 8 years. In general, when do you start building cash and getting more conservative in anticipation of withdrawing funds? Thanks, Neil
Read Answer Asked by Neil on August 02, 2018
Q: Hi 5i team :
I want to know how resilient is my portfolio to a downturn of the TSX. Can I use the beta value for each stock ?, is this a correct method ?. If so , where can I find the beta values ?, Some brokerages show a value (i.e. tdwaterhouse) . is this value reliable ?, how is the value calculated ?. Thanks for your help
Read Answer Asked by Alejandro (Alex) on August 02, 2018
Q: Hello 5i Team

The passive index fund industry is dominated by BlackRock, Vanguard, and State Street. Seen together, these three giant, passive asset managers already constitute the largest shareholder in at least 40 percent of all U.S. listed companies and 88 percent of the S&P 500 firms. What are your thoughts in terms of the big three controlling the corporations and what happens when there is a market correction or meltdown. Would there be any buyers left and also individual stock investors could get into deep trouble.

https://www.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/content/view/30AD689509AAD62F5B677E916C28C4B6/S1469356917000064a.pdf/hidden_power_of_the_big_three_passive_index_funds_reconcentration_of_corporate_ownership_and_new_financial_risk.pdf

Appreciate the good work done by 5i team.

Thanks
Ninad
Read Answer Asked by Ninad on August 01, 2018
Q: Can you suggest tools to monitor market breadth or flow of funds in and out of different sectors?

Are these criteria that you watch?
Read Answer Asked by Mark on July 31, 2018
Q: Hi Peter and Team,

My question is about what is the best strategy and behavior during a downturn in the markets?

From my reading of previous answered questions and on other posts on the internet, the advice seems to be, do not sell while the market is dropping. How can one be disciplined enough not to do it? What if one stock in our portfolio is dropping more that the rest during a downturn in the markets? At what point while the market is dropping, should we consider buying more quality stocks?

Thanks again for your good work.

Marvin
Read Answer Asked by Marvin on July 31, 2018
Q: Hi,
Have inflationary pressures become real due to the tarrifs? Do you expect this to start having impact on prices and therefore on the stock market? I suspect Trump might back pedal once these tariffs start impacting markets. What are your thoughts? Thanks.

Shyam
Read Answer Asked by Shyam on July 31, 2018
Q: Hi group I am taking a bath on tech stock both in US and Canada . Looking like market is going to value on these stock as opposed to growth. I also am losing a lot on financials like Visa + PayPal. What strategy should I use going fwd . Preserve capitol or wait out what happening or? . I know that this info is scattered info but generally what is your thoughts going fwd Thanks for your guidance
Read Answer Asked by Terence on July 31, 2018
Q: What is Blockchain Technology. How does it work ? What is the Future ? RAK
Read Answer Asked by bob on July 31, 2018
Q: I appreciate you noting the Insider Ownership in your reports. Where does a retail investor best access Insider and Institutional Ownership for CDN and US stocks. Thanks.
Read Answer Asked by Murray on July 30, 2018