Q: I have only US$ available and tend to invest only in inter-listed companies (e.g. a Cdn bank, Canadian Oilco, and other large caps). I asked both iTRADE and RBC-DI *NOT* to convert the dividends such companies pay in C$, and instead let me accumulate C$. My understanding is that an investor has the legal right to demand the bank NOT to convert dvidends.
However both brokers I name here claim that to avoid unwanted Forex conversion, I need to ask them to journal the holdings over to the “side” I want.
In your experience, is this normal? Or can one insist the broker leave the holdings in the currency of original purchase? Do the brokers have a legal right to make the above-noted demand?
This issue affects many 5i members:
I had wanted both brokers not to convert because they were applying the worst possible exchange rates. Many of your members will have holdings bought on TSX where the company pays dividend in US$. AQN (inter-listed) is one of several Canadian companies that pays dividends in US$ . I believe you likely have many members who object to the very disadvantageous exchange rates applied by brokers — and certainly many would object to “automatic” conversion, surely.
If brokers are within their rights, are there not laws, rules & regs that require brokers to apply FAIR exchange rates?
However both brokers I name here claim that to avoid unwanted Forex conversion, I need to ask them to journal the holdings over to the “side” I want.
In your experience, is this normal? Or can one insist the broker leave the holdings in the currency of original purchase? Do the brokers have a legal right to make the above-noted demand?
This issue affects many 5i members:
I had wanted both brokers not to convert because they were applying the worst possible exchange rates. Many of your members will have holdings bought on TSX where the company pays dividend in US$. AQN (inter-listed) is one of several Canadian companies that pays dividends in US$ . I believe you likely have many members who object to the very disadvantageous exchange rates applied by brokers — and certainly many would object to “automatic” conversion, surely.
If brokers are within their rights, are there not laws, rules & regs that require brokers to apply FAIR exchange rates?