Q: I feel compelled to chime in on the RRSP discussion, with my personal scenario.
- 25 years still to work
- marginal tax rate 43.4%
- highest tax bracket 50.4%
- Assumed yearly return of 10%
Option 1: Utilize the RRSP for 10k/year:
Balance after 25 years = 1.08 million. Worst case scenario (unlikely) I pay 50.4% tax on the entire balance = 536k remaining.
Option 2: Pay tax on the 10k at 43.4% and have 5,660 left to invest in a cash account.
Balance after 25 years = 612k. Pay capital gain tax of **118k = 493k remaining.
**Capital gain = 612k less cost base of 141k (5,660 X 25 years) = 470k. X 50.4% X 0.5 = 118k.
I am still better off in option 1 with 536k rather than the 493k in option 2. Note that it is also very unlikely I pay the highest tax rate on the entire balance. In reality I will likely to much better than the tax rate used in option 1.
Open to hear if you think I'm missing anything?
- 25 years still to work
- marginal tax rate 43.4%
- highest tax bracket 50.4%
- Assumed yearly return of 10%
Option 1: Utilize the RRSP for 10k/year:
Balance after 25 years = 1.08 million. Worst case scenario (unlikely) I pay 50.4% tax on the entire balance = 536k remaining.
Option 2: Pay tax on the 10k at 43.4% and have 5,660 left to invest in a cash account.
Balance after 25 years = 612k. Pay capital gain tax of **118k = 493k remaining.
**Capital gain = 612k less cost base of 141k (5,660 X 25 years) = 470k. X 50.4% X 0.5 = 118k.
I am still better off in option 1 with 536k rather than the 493k in option 2. Note that it is also very unlikely I pay the highest tax rate on the entire balance. In reality I will likely to much better than the tax rate used in option 1.
Open to hear if you think I'm missing anything?