Q: Hi again! Just following up on the TFSA portion of my last question, where you suggested starting with an ETF like XCS and gradually adding individual securities from your portfolio as funds increase. I’ve found a firm (WealthSimple) that offers zero-fee fractional trading, so I’m considering the possibility of investing fractionally in one of your portfolios. While it seems like the return rate would be proportional, I wanted to get your insights on any negative implications that could be associated with fractional investing in one of your offered portfolios - if there are any.
My Plan A is to fractionally invest in one of your portfolios, but I’m open to considering a high-growth ETF if you think that would be a better strategy. I’m also comfortable investing in an American ETF if it could potentially offer a higher yield. However, with WealthSimple, there’s a $10 monthly fee to invest in American shares, which totals $120 a year. Given that my TFSA currently holds about $5,000, I would need a return of roughly 2.5% just to break even if I opt for the growth portfolio, which includes American companies. While this fee should ideally become negligible as I continue to average into the TFSA over time, it’s still a notable-ish consideration at the moment.
Additionally, do you believe the growth portfolio will outperform the balanced portfolio in the long term, and if so, why, considering its underperformance compared to the balanced portfolio over the last 10 years? Is the current outperformance of the balanced portfolio something you anticipated in this shorter timeframe? Given my long-term investment strategy, which portfolio would you recommend, and why? While the growth portfolio's strategy aligns more closely with my investment goals, I want to ensure it’s the right choice, especially considering the balanced portfolio's stronger performance over a similar time frame.
Thanks again for your guidance!
My Plan A is to fractionally invest in one of your portfolios, but I’m open to considering a high-growth ETF if you think that would be a better strategy. I’m also comfortable investing in an American ETF if it could potentially offer a higher yield. However, with WealthSimple, there’s a $10 monthly fee to invest in American shares, which totals $120 a year. Given that my TFSA currently holds about $5,000, I would need a return of roughly 2.5% just to break even if I opt for the growth portfolio, which includes American companies. While this fee should ideally become negligible as I continue to average into the TFSA over time, it’s still a notable-ish consideration at the moment.
Additionally, do you believe the growth portfolio will outperform the balanced portfolio in the long term, and if so, why, considering its underperformance compared to the balanced portfolio over the last 10 years? Is the current outperformance of the balanced portfolio something you anticipated in this shorter timeframe? Given my long-term investment strategy, which portfolio would you recommend, and why? While the growth portfolio's strategy aligns more closely with my investment goals, I want to ensure it’s the right choice, especially considering the balanced portfolio's stronger performance over a similar time frame.
Thanks again for your guidance!