skip to content
  1. Home
  2. >
  3. Investment Q&A
You can view 3 more answers this month. Sign up for a free trial for unlimited access.

Investment Q&A

Not investment advice or solicitation to buy/sell securities. Do your own due diligence and/or consult an advisor.

Q: I am looking to follow the S&P 500. I am not sure what etf is best to use. I have seen you recommend VFV in Q&A but your model etf portfolios hold ZSP. Is there one you would choose over another? Is there another option I should consider? If you can advise if it is best to put in a register or unregistered account. I have room in both my TFSA and RRSP.

Thank you for the great service.
Read Answer Asked by Justin on March 16, 2020
Q: Hi,
Multuiple questions here, please deduct the credits you think are appropriate.

1) Can you please explain when it makes sense to hold a hedged version of an ETF
2) If one holds a Canadian ETF with US holdings, how does taxation work? Does it change whether they are held in a cash acct, TFSA, or RRSP and how?
Read Answer Asked by S on March 13, 2020
Q: Hello,
Question regarding the 30 day rule on repurchasing a stock that was sold for a capital loss. I sold Enb.to for a small capital loss in a non registered account.
If I decide to re-purchase the stock within the 30 day period I understand that the capital loss is not allowed, as I sold for a very small loss that really does not matter.
My question is; what if any any other penalty or other issue to consider before re-purchasing (my example enb.to) for a much lower price than I sold it for?

Thanks,
Randy D
Read Answer Asked by Randy on March 13, 2020
Q: Hi!
A few times there has been mention of 5i members declaring the subscription for a deduction for their income tax return.

Hoping someone would know under which section this can be done using Ufile?

Thanks.
Read Answer Asked by Rino on March 09, 2020
Q: Hi there,
When there is a corporate takeover and one receives a fraction of the new shares, that fraction of a new share may be paid out as "cash in lieu". Is that cash in lieu treated as a capital gain/loss or is it considered dividend income?
Thank you.
Read Answer Asked by John on March 09, 2020
Q: Hi 5i, Another question about your model ETF portfolio.
This one is about VE-T and VEE-T.
They trade on the Toronto exchange, Does that make them like Canadian ETFs?
I mean, are their dividends eligible for the tax credit? Or are they fully taxed, just like US
ETFs?
Many thanks. Shan
Read Answer Asked by Shanthi on March 06, 2020
Q: My instincts predict the federal government will bump the capital gains tax from 50 to 75 or maybe even 100 and that there won't be any grandfather clause, ie immediate day of March budget. Were this a known fact to happen, please offer your thoughts on what you would recommend. Thanks!
Read Answer Asked by Bill on February 21, 2020
Q: A comment on Shirley of this morning regarding tax forms (T3, T4, T5, LP tax forms..etc.), now all of these can be downloaded directly from Revenue Canada website directly to your tax filing program. The only issue is that you have to wait until all of them are received by RCA which is usually around first week of April.
Read Answer Asked by Saad on February 21, 2020
Q: My TFSA and RRSP are topped up and I have a an unregistered account,what would the best tax advantageous stocks to buy,would it be dividend tax credit stocks and if so could you give me a couple of companies that have good management,growth and a rising dividend ....thanks
Read Answer Asked by Greg on February 21, 2020
Q: Hi Gentlemen,
If I make a donation in stocks with loss to my adult children, can I claim the loss ?
Thanks Best regards.
Read Answer Asked by Djamel on February 06, 2020
Q: Alexandra has been asking about crystallizing capital gains to apply against capital losses (which are presumably already realized).

If my understanding of her question is correct, she should be advised that there is no need to wait 30-days to repurchase stocks sold at a gain.

Further, there really isn't a need to sell a stock just to offset a capital loss carry-over, as that capital loss carry-over carries forward indefinitely.

You can never say never, but the risk of the government undoing the capital loss carry-over benefit is minimal. There has been talk about increasing capital gains inclusion rates, but that's not going to matter to Alexandra if she capital loss carry-overs.

Hopefully this is helpful to Alexandra.

Read Answer Asked by Christopher on February 06, 2020
Q: Further to my recent question about crystallizing gains to apply against capital losses, how would you implement this ? There will be 5 stocks that I will sell but will re-buy after 30 days, i.e. syz, engh, kxs, wsp, cjt.
In this market,
1) what strategy would you use for selling in terms of timing ,
2) would you temporarily replace with something else and if so, what would that be, and
3) would you do all 5 or just one at a time ?
Thanks again.
Read Answer Asked by Alexandra on February 04, 2020
Q: I have found that for some ADRs, the home country (eg., the Netherlands, Spain) withholds a portion of dividends, even when the shares are in registered accounts, and of course such tax can't be written off against Canadian taxes. Company websites don't seem to make this information available. Is there some way of identifying in advance when such withholding will occur, or can you offer more general advice regarding how best to invest in individual, non-US companies, while receiving the full value of dividends paid?
Read Answer Asked by don on January 31, 2020
Q: I received a nice payment yesterday from the Amaya litigation. In a non-registered account, would this be regarded as a capital gain?
Read Answer Asked by richard on January 29, 2020