skip to content
  1. Home
  2. >
  3. Investment Q&A
You can view 3 more answers this month. Sign up for a free trial for unlimited access.

Investment Q&A

Not investment advice or solicitation to buy/sell securities. Do your own due diligence and/or consult an advisor.

Q: Although I am using CRH in the heading this question is really applicable to any number of situations where a share price drops on an analyst's "downgrade", especially when there is no material news on the company e.g. - management malfeasance, loss of a contract etc.

I am not particularly concerned here about the company's future and fully expect the share price to go back to where it was relatively soon, especially in light of the fact that the target price is higher that what it was trading at and that the consensus price is much lower that the new target.


But I am left wondering why this or any other stock would have dropped so much. Is it because it was an RBC analyst and as a matter of course, all RBC brokers are instructed to put in sell orders (their clients are probably all up given the recent share price increases) to show clients the value of their firm's research (and then start buying it back when the price drops) or are there trading programs that always sell on downgrades or is this a particularly "good" analyst with a wide following or am I just being too cynical?

As I said, this isn't just about CRH and RBC. Or is every situation so different that you can't generalize and this is just "noise" that should be taken with a grain of salt?

Appreciate your insight?

Paul F.
Read Answer Asked by Paul on November 28, 2016
Q: Hello Folks:
In reading your answers to previous questions on GILD you recommend the company for it's strong cash position and low valuation, but recommend having the patience of a 2 year outlook. I have owned GILD for several years and not done very well as of late. Being I am 70 yrs. old should I hang in with GILD or move into another health related company? I have a full position with Johnson & Johnson, but am unaware of other very good health care options. I am not a frequent trader, tending to hold mostly American blue-chip companies,and welcome your advice...I greatly appreciate your good service!
brian
Read Answer Asked by Brian on November 28, 2016
Q: Do you think CRH has risen too quickly recently and is a sell candidate? I note that the 3 month return is 75% without a lot of news. I have owned the stock since the $3 level and I am talking myself into selling. I recall the Auto Canada, Badger and Patient Home Monitoring debacles and this feels similar. Too well liked, excessive momentum.
Read Answer Asked by Chris on November 25, 2016
Q: Hi,

I am holding RBC Life Science and Tech mutual fund (RBF1030)which is a nice mix of U.S. technology and health care stocks.
What would be a good ETF to replace it or, alternatively, which stocks combination would replace it advantageously ?

Thanks again for your exceptional service,

Jacques
Read Answer Asked by Jacques on November 23, 2016
Q: I have held Novartis for a few years and still show a profit of ~33%. However it has dropped significantly in the last 18 months. In the pharma space, I also hold Knight Therapeutic (GUD) and Johnson & Johnson (JNJ). I wonder if Novartis is still worth keeping or should I consider switching to something else (or increasing my holding in J&J or GUD). It represents ~1% of my portfolio which is well diversified but light on pharma. Although not your primary field of expertise, I would still appreciate any light you could shed on the company. Thank you for your valuable insights.
Read Answer Asked by jacques on November 18, 2016
Q: I'm considering buying some GILD.My portfolio is all CDN stocks so it should benefit from some diversification and I feel US stocks may gain some strength under Trump.Obviously GILD is very cheap which reminds me a little of Concordia when I bought what I thought was an undervalued health care stock only to watch it nose dive.I also noticed a few reputable investment firms loading up over the last 2 months.My other choice was to buy PBH which is a great company but very expensive.What are your thoughts on a very cheap GILD which adds some diversification vs a fairly expensive PBH which is currently performing much better? I find i'm more of a GARP than a value investor but I appreciate getting a great stock on sale.
Read Answer Asked by Adam on November 18, 2016