Q: This is to follow-up on the question posed by Linda on Jan 9/14 re. tax issues/negative factors to be considered with holding US (or other foreign)dividend paying stocks in a TFSA. Your response was that, yes, in a TFSA witholding tax will be applied on foreign dividends: in an RRSP it will not.
I'm not sure how much weight to give this info when structuring your TFSA. Should it just be -No- TFSA is not the optimal place to hold foreign equity - get your foreign exposure elsewhere. Or - Yes - this is something you should be aware of - it will act as a bit of a drag on returns - but should be subordinate to the over-all objective of your TFSA.
Specifically, I would like to re-structue my TFSA to replicate a mini stand-alone portfolio. And to do so I was considering the Mawer Balanced Fund as a simple one step solution - 40% FI; 20% Can. equity: 40% foreign equity - MER below 1% and consistently outperforms its benchmark.
Question: should the negative tax implications on the 40% foreign component be cause enough not to follow this approach?
Thank-you
I'm not sure how much weight to give this info when structuring your TFSA. Should it just be -No- TFSA is not the optimal place to hold foreign equity - get your foreign exposure elsewhere. Or - Yes - this is something you should be aware of - it will act as a bit of a drag on returns - but should be subordinate to the over-all objective of your TFSA.
Specifically, I would like to re-structue my TFSA to replicate a mini stand-alone portfolio. And to do so I was considering the Mawer Balanced Fund as a simple one step solution - 40% FI; 20% Can. equity: 40% foreign equity - MER below 1% and consistently outperforms its benchmark.
Question: should the negative tax implications on the 40% foreign component be cause enough not to follow this approach?
Thank-you