Investment Q&A

Q: I see the techinicals on oil have broken down with a next support at $86. Would this be a good time to step out of SGY or partialy step out due to its normal volitility as a junior?

Q: re: SGY Surge & John O'Connell' comments

One of my biggest challenges is "sifting through" comments made by industry guests/pundits/experts whether on the TV, radio or in an article. I often wonder if there is any ulterior motives at work behind what they say and have no doubt at times there is. After all we are talking about money.

Mr. O'Connell' comments on Surge for me however made sense, and it isn't the first time I have heard similar comments of this kind regarding this company.

He feels the growth per share would be considerably inferior if the company wasn't paying such a large dividend. He was very complimentary regarding Paul Colburn' management abilities and referenced what he did at Cresent Point. However when it comes to Surge, John mentioned Paul made allot of acquisitions, paid brokers allot of money in commissions, and that production/share growth hasn't been all that spectacular. He went on to say he wished Paul wouldn't pay such a high dividend and that he's "on a bit of a treadmill" trying to keep up with high decline rates and that the high dividend is a crushing problem for him as it is very expensive money.

I have done very well with Surge up to this point (40% after dividend) and would like to hear your thoughts regarding Mr. O'Connell' comments and what the 5i Team expects for Surge moving forward.

As usual, thank you for all you do... would be lost without you

Gord

Q: Please give us your opinion on the results posted by SGY and WCP and which do you think will have the better capital appreciation over the next 12 months.

Q: WCP/SGY: Hi Peter and team. I own both and am considering adding more, potentially of each. Benji Galander, truly a contrarian, is decidedly negative on SGY considering it very risky with very little cash. How would you rebut and how do you view a decision between these two today? Or should I also be considering TORC or others in the field?

Thanks

K

Q: Hello Peter and Team,
I am looking to add a little punch to the Energy sector of an otherwise diversified portfolio. Energy currently makes up almost 20%, so I am not looking to add, but to hopefully refine. I am considering a swap of Surge (SGY) for Vermillion (VET). I like them both, but am leaning towards the income feature of Surge as well as the continuation of good results as was indicated in the last Q report. Could I have your thoughts to this?

Q: Hi Team, Could you please comment on the earnings reported by Surge Enegy (SGY) today? Thanks,

Q: I own SGY now and would like to add more. Is now a good time or wait for a pullback. Also, is this the same management at surge since 1998. SGY was quite a bit higher in 2006 and also in 2012. Why the downfall? I just purchased SGY about 3 months ago and assumed it was a recent new company. Thanks, being able to buy and ask questions later is a big, big help. This 5i is the best and I have purchased about 8-10 other investment letters and some where real rip-offs, promoting THEIR stocks so that they could profit or get out?

Q: Hello 5i - as always thank you for all help.
I am trying to decide between BTE & CPG, or another dividend paying energy company. Your opinion is much appreciated.

Craig

Q: Re SGY - I've heard it said Surge is similar to an early stage Crescent Point story as they are intending to acquire and build out substantial resources. Do you agree with this and if so, do you have any timeline guesstimates that might indicate how long would be an appropriate hold period, in order to let them work their plan and potentially see much higher share price? Thanks

Q: Surge Energy has been VERY strong over the last week while the rest of the oil stocks have been relatively weak. Any rumours and news that might be causing this?

Q: Is Surge Energy a suitable investment for a conservative income oriented investor? I currently own BTE, CNQ, SU. Thank you.

Q: Hi Peter & Team, Surge Energy (SGY) has a yield now of just about 9%. Its getting me concerned as i think the share price needs to appreciate so that the yield is lowered. Your thoughts?

Thank,Ilesh

Q: Painted pony, surge or tourmaline for most upside in the next 6 months, risk is not a factor . Dave

Q: WCP or SGY if you could only choose one?

Q: what is the best choice for a company with a dividend in excess of 4% with good growth prospects for a 3 year or more hold? Sector not impt. Thanks

Q: Hi Peter and Team, just an FYI for all who are interested in Surge, SGY. I believe the CEO will be on BNN today on Weekly with Andrew McCreath, I believe at 4:30 pm ET. Should be interesting if nothing else! Get well soon...Rocky lol Great Cause/Charity Work. Thanks!

Q: Hi again Peter,

Another question on SGY (Surge). I was wondering if the dividend yield at around 8% is a little high. Should it not be in and around the 5% range? Seems like investors are actually saying the yield is unsustainable? Your comments are appreciated.

Q: Hi Peter,

SGY (Surge Energy) has had a slight pullback since it touched $8 recently. What is your view on SGY going forward? Thanks

Q: Hi,

You seem to really like SGY and it is having a nice run right now. I do hold some in my non-registered account.
I am thinking of adding BXE as it has lagged a bit.
What are your thoughts on BXE or add SGY as I only have half a position?

Thanks,Irshad.

Q: Hello Peter and all at 5i: I have very little in the oil and gas sector, I do have GEI and SU but they are a small percentage of my overall portfolio and wonder if it is too late in this move up and if not would you please list your favourite names at this time. Thank you Barb